Pyramid of Adversary Profiling (POAP) Against Cyber Warfare
The Pyramid of Adversary Profiling (POAP) offers a structured and dynamic approach to understanding and mitigating the threats posed by cyber warfare. Cyber warfare refers to the use of cyberattacks .
The Pyramid of Adversary Profiling (POAP) offers a structured and dynamic approach to understanding and mitigating the threats posed by cyber warfare. Cyber warfare refers to the use of cyberattacks by nation-states or state-sponsored actors to target critical infrastructure, steal sensitive information, or disrupt systems to achieve political, economic, or military objectives. POAP is a powerful tool for analyzing these complex and evolving threats.
Why POAP is Effective Against Cyber Warfare
Cyber warfare is one of the most sophisticated and strategic forms of cyberattacks, often involving state-sponsored groups with considerable resources, expertise, and goals. The attacks are highly targeted, sometimes using advanced persistent threats (APTs), zero-day vulnerabilities, and multi-vector campaigns to infiltrate and disrupt organizations or even nations.
The Pyramid of Adversary Profiling (POAP) helps in defending against these cyber threats by providing a holistic framework to analyze the adversaries' identities, motivations, attack methods, and timing. With its multi-layered approach, POAP offers a detailed view of the adversary and assists in proactive defense strategies.
How POAP Works Against Cyber Warfare
The POAP framework is built around five core layers: Who, Why, What, How, and When. Here's how each of these layers helps organizations and governments understand and mitigate the risks posed by cyber warfare.
1️⃣ Who: Adversary Identity
Who the attacker is provides critical insight into the nature and origin of the threat. In the case of cyber warfare, the adversaries are typically nation-states, state-sponsored actors, or advanced persistent threat (APT) groups, often tied to specific political or military goals.
For example, groups like Fancy Bear (APT28) or Lazarus Group are known to be linked with specific state-sponsored cyber espionage activities. Understanding the identity of the adversary helps predict their tactics, targets, and objectives.
2️⃣ Why: Motivation & Intent
The motivation behind cyber warfare is often linked to political, military, or economic goals. Adversaries in cyber warfare seek to disrupt infrastructure, steal sensitive state or corporate data, or damage critical assets to achieve political leverage or military advantages.
For example, a cyber warfare group may target a country’s power grid to destabilize the economy or military networks to disrupt strategic operations.
Understanding why the attack is occurring helps organizations prioritize high-value assets and build defenses based on adversary objectives.
3️⃣ What: Targeted Assets
In cyber warfare, the targeted assets are usually critical infrastructures, such as power grids, military systems, financial institutions, telecommunications, and government databases.
By understanding what is being targeted, defenders can focus on securing these critical assets through robust defense measures like network segmentation, intrusion detection systems (IDS), and redundant backup systems.
Example: A cyber warfare attack may aim to infiltrate and disable a military communications network. Protecting these assets would require highly encrypted communications, secure access controls, and constant monitoring for suspicious activities.
4️⃣ How: Execution Methods
How the attack is executed often involves sophisticated tactics like spear-phishing, zero-day exploits, supply chain attacks, or botnet attacks. State-sponsored groups in cyber warfare typically employ advanced and custom-made malware or attacks that leave few traces.
For example, a zero-day vulnerability in widely used software like Windows or Cisco routers might be exploited to gain unauthorized access. Additionally, supply chain attacks (such as the SolarWinds hack) can be used to compromise third-party software, further complicating detection.
Defenders must stay ahead of these attacks by regular patching, employing threat hunting techniques, using sandboxing to detect malicious activities, and deploying multi-layered defense strategies.
5️⃣ When: Attack Timing
In cyber warfare, the timing of the attack is often aligned with geopolitical events, military conflicts, or economic crises. For example, cyberattacks might be launched at the same time as military strikes or during political elections to maximize the disruption.
A cyber warfare group may launch a coordinated cyberattack during a period of heightened geopolitical tension, using attacks to destabilize the adversary’s confidence or create economic turmoil.
By understanding when these attacks might occur, organizations can implement timing-based defenses, such as increasing monitoring around sensitive political events, critical infrastructure, or election periods.
Example: Using POAP to Defend Against Cyber Warfare
Let's walk through a practical case of defending against a cyber warfare attack using the Pyramid of Adversary Profiling (POAP) framework:
Scenario: Defense Against a Cyber Warfare Attack on National Infrastructure
A nation-state adversary is attempting to compromise a country's power grid to cause widespread disruption during a politically sensitive time. They aim to affect economic stability and shift public opinion in their favor.
Step 1: Who – Adversary Identity
The adversary is identified as a state-sponsored cyber group known for targeting critical infrastructure (e.g., ElectricityGridGroup). This group has previously launched attacks on similar power grids and is affiliated with a nation-state with strategic interests in destabilizing the region.
Step 2: Why – Motivation & Intent
The motivation is geopolitical—to disrupt the target country’s energy sector, affect the daily lives of its citizens, and cause public unrest. The intent is to undermine confidence in the government's ability to maintain essential services during a time of heightened political sensitivity (e.g., a national election).
Step 3: What – Targeted Assets
The primary targeted assets are the country’s power grid infrastructure and energy management systems, which control and monitor the distribution of electricity across the nation.
To protect against this, the country focuses on strengthening the power grid’s cybersecurity, ensuring redundant power sources, and enhancing incident response plans to limit any damage from an attack.
Step 4: How – Execution Methods
The attackers may use spear-phishing emails targeting key personnel within the energy sector, potentially planting malicious payloads that allow remote access to grid control systems. They might also exploit a zero-day vulnerability in a critical piece of control software to gain access.
The defensive team deploys email filtering systems, implements multi-factor authentication (MFA) for accessing control systems, and conducts regular penetration testing to identify potential vulnerabilities before they are exploited.
Step 5: When – Attack Timing
The adversary is likely to launch the attack before a major political event, such as a national election or international summit, to maximize the impact.
The government schedules extra monitoring around key dates, preparing its cybersecurity teams for potential incidents and deploying backup systems to maintain control of critical infrastructure if compromised.
Why POAP is Effective Against Cyber Warfare
Holistic View: POAP provides a 360-degree view of the cyber adversary, including their identity, motivations, and methods, enabling defenders to anticipate attacks before they happen.
Dynamic Profiling: Unlike static models, POAP’s focus on understanding adversary behavior (e.g., why they attack) allows organizations to adapt their defenses in real time to evolving threats.
Proactive Defense: By understanding the who, why, what, how, and when, defenders can proactively implement preventive measures and incident response strategies, reducing the effectiveness of attacks.
Adversary-Centric Approach: POAP focuses on the adversary’s strategic goals, which is crucial in cyber warfare, where attacks are often part of a larger political or military campaign.
Last updated