How the Pyramid of Adversary Profiling Works ?
Pyramid of Adversary Profiling
The Pyramid of Adversary Profiling is designed to provide a holistic and dynamic framework for understanding cyber adversaries. Instead of focusing solely on known Indicators of Compromise (IOCs) or Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs) (which are vulnerable to change), the Pyramid provides a deeper, more predictive way to analyze who the adversary is, why they act, how they execute their attacks, and when they strike.
The pyramid operates by layering the analysis of the adversary’s profile, starting from the foundational elements (the “who” and “why”) and then moving to the more tactical aspects (the “how” and “when”). This framework enhances defensive capabilities by focusing on long-term behaviors, patterns, and motivations rather than just temporary attack markers.
Step-by-Step Process: How the Pyramid Works
1️⃣ Who: Adversary Identity
Goal: Identify the threat actor or group.
Process:
This is the foundational level of the pyramid where the focus is on identifying who the adversary is.
Does the attacker belong to a known group (e.g., APT, cybercriminal, hacktivist, insider threat)?
The analysis involves studying patterns across attack vectors, previous actions, and attributes (such as their preferred target industries, tactics, or geographic areas of operation).
Understanding who the adversary is can help in recognizing their motivations and potential future actions.
2️⃣ Why: Motivation and Intent
Goal: Understand the reason behind the attack.
Process:
This level focuses on the motive behind the attack.
Why is this adversary attacking? Is it financially motivated (ransomware), politically motivated (hacktivism), espionage-driven (corporate or nation-state), or simply opportunistic?
Knowing the motivation behind the attack allows organizations to better predict what types of targets or systems will be next.
It also helps security teams understand the nature of the threat (for example, is it intended to cause disruption, gain financial profit, or damage a reputation?).
3️⃣ What: Targeted Assets
Goal: Identify the targeted assets.
Process:
The focus shifts to what systems, data, or infrastructure the adversary is aiming to compromise.
The analysis looks at key assets that might be targeted: financial systems, intellectual property, customer data, operational technologies, etc.
Once the assets are identified, it becomes easier to prioritize security measures, such as enhanced protection for certain critical systems or sensitive data.
4️⃣ How: Execution Methods
Goal: Understand how the adversary conducts the attack.
Process:
The attacker’s Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs) come into play here.
How does the adversary penetrate the system? Do they use phishing, malware, social engineering, or zero-day exploits?
Understanding attack methods enables the organization to deploy defensive mechanisms to detect and mitigate those specific TTPs.
Here, we focus on preventative defense, as understanding how the adversary works allows for proactive security measures.
5️⃣ When: Attack Timing
Goal: Predict when the adversary is likely to strike.
Process:
The timing of attacks is crucial to understanding the adversary’s patterns.
When does the adversary strike? Is it tied to specific events such as major product launches, public announcements, or financial quarters?
Attackers may target organizations during off-peak hours or holidays when security monitoring might be reduced.
Analyzing attack timing can help an organization anticipate threats and prepare defenses before they are needed, implementing timely countermeasures.
Integrating the Pyramid into Security Operations
Once the Pyramid of Adversary Profiling is fully understood, organizations can integrate it into their security operations by:
Continuous Threat Intelligence Gathering: Constantly monitor, analyze, and assess who is behind the attack and why they are targeting specific assets.
Behavioral Analytics: Implement user behavior analytics (UBA) and anomaly detection systems that focus on identifying the methods and patterns of adversaries rather than relying only on static signatures.
Contextual Risk Assessment: Use the "What" and "Why" layers to prioritize the defense of critical systems, especially those related to intellectual property, finances, and sensitive customer data.
Proactive Defense Mechanisms: Based on the "How" layer, develop threat-hunting and response strategies that actively detect and neutralize adversary techniques such as social engineering, phishing, and malware.
Timing-based Defense Strategy: Enhance security measures and monitoring during suspected attack periods based on adversary timing patterns. For example, if attacks often occur during financial reporting periods, your organization can increase vigilance around these times.
Why It’s More Effective Than Traditional Models
Behavioral Focus: Unlike the Pyramid of Pain, which is heavily reliant on static indicators like IP addresses or hashes that attackers can easily change, the Pyramid of Adversary Profiling emphasizes understanding the adversary’s tactics and behaviors. This makes it more adaptable to evolving threats.
Proactive and Predictive: By analyzing motives, execution methods, and timing, it helps organizations anticipate and prevent attacks, rather than simply reacting to them.
Holistic Understanding: The model offers a deeper understanding of the attacker’s intent and capabilities, which is key in dealing with sophisticated, evolving threats such as APT (Advanced Persistent Threats) or insider threats.
Last updated